Thursday, April 23, 2009

Jeremy Bowen election diary

Jeremy Bowen election diary

BBC Middle East Editor Jeremy Bowen's diary of the Israeli election.

9 FEBRUARY
It was sunny and warm in the Jewish settlement of Ofra in the occupied West Bank this morning. Yoram Cohen was inspecting his vines.

He is a winemaker with a growing reputation. The wine critic of the Israel daily Ha'aretz, Daniel Rogov, recently gave him 90 points for his Cabernet Sauvignon. Most Ha'aretz readers are from the side of Israel that believes that the settlements have been a disaster for the country.

Yoram Cohen
Yoram Cohen's wine has won praise from the critics
Yoram grinned. "If I wasn't from a settlement Rogov would have given me an even higher score."

Ofra was founded in 1975. It has acquired a well established air that makes it feel permanent. The trees are tall and thick. Gardens have well-established shrubs. You can see why many Israelis believe that the settlements are going to be here for ever.

Israelis classify their political views according to what they think about the idea of exchanging land Israel has occupied since the 1967 war for peace with the Palestinians - or in the case of the Golan Heights, with Syria.

Those who believe in the idea most - who also think Israel needs to get out of places like Ofra - call themselves left wing. Those who hate the idea are on the right, and among them, the settlers are a powerful and dynamic political force.

Yoram believes that the land was given to the Jews by God. Part of his vineyard looks a bit of a mess, because it has been the seventh year in the planting cycle and according to Jewish religious law he has let it go fallow.

Like many Israelis of all political views, even on the last day before the polls opened he wasn't sure which party was going to get his vote. He joked about it.

Yoram Cohen and Jeremy Bowen at vineyard
The vineyard is part of a settlement established in the 1970s
"My heart tells me to vote for the right wing but my brain tells me to vote for the left because the left goes to war when we need one, and the right does the opposite of what I want."

Yoram didn't like Ariel Sharon's decision to pull soldiers and settlers out of Gaza in 2005. He said that when it came to it he would probably vote for one of the small right wing parties.

The election, as ever in Israel, is dominated by the Palestinian issue. But no party has made a convincing case of how to deal with it.

Israelis have become very sceptical about the prospects for peace, just like the Palestinians. Years of bloodshed and failed negotiations have left big scars.

Yoram Cohen has learnt to ignore politicians.

"Thirty-five years ago Henry Kissinger told us we'd have to leave and we're still here. We're building, putting in more grapes. Politicians just talk. I get on with my life as if there isn't a question mark over it."

His wine, by the way, is excellent.

8 FEBRUARY

Israel feels as if it has developed an immunity to election fever. Not surprising, perhaps, since this country has a lot of elections.

Relentlessly negative advertising by all sides does not help much either.

Binyamin Netanyahu campaigning in the northern Israeli village of Aniam, 8 February 2009
Binyamin Netanyahu's lead in the polls has been slipping

This election feels very low key.

The first Israeli election I covered was in 1996. I seem to remember that the streets were full of posters, and crowds of youngsters from competing parties crowded round cars at traffic lights giving out leaflets and stickers.

This morning I met a leading Israeli pollster, Camil Fuchs, on the campus of Tel Aviv University.

He also does polling for Channel 10 TV and Ha'aretz newspaper. I wanted to talk about the way Israeli elections are always about war and peace.

He said they were, but this time he had not heard the parties saying much about peace. Plenty of them talked about war though.

Camil said that his polling showed that Israelis believed the war in Gaza had been inconclusive. Voters, he said, wanted to believe in peace, but did not trust the peace process, or the Palestinians.

The man who at this stage looks most likely to form a government is the leader of the Likud, Binyamin Netanyahu.

Mr Netanyahu says that Israel missed an opportunity in Gaza to finish Hamas. He promises to finish the job.

In the final polls the centrist Kadima party, led by Tzipi Livni, has been closing the gap on Mr Netanyahu's Likud.

But the electoral arithmetic of coalition-building is on his side. He is likely to have more allies in the next Knesset.

If Binyamin Netanyahu is not the next prime minister, it will be an upset for the pollsters.

It has happened before.

He won that election back in 1996, beating Shimon Peres by the narrowest of margins.

It was so close that the country went to sleep that night thinking that Mr Peres was going to keep the job he had inherited after the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin the year before.

So when the exit polls come out after the voting ends on Tuesday, be a little cautious until the votes are counted.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home